Eugene David
...The One-Minute Pundit

Wednesday, May 04, 2005


In a more useful link from ArtsJournal.com, one of the world's leading conductors writes (and finances) an "opera," with predictable results:

[Lorin] Maazel has merely provided a soundtrack to the story. The vocal lines are characterless and his score adds nothing to the uncertain dramatic trajectory or to the work's rather top-heavy structure (the first act lasts 100 minutes, the second less than 50), with music that is a lexicon of the most obvious borrowings.

The appearance of a children's chorus provokes writing that might have been left over from Lionel Bart's Oliver!; the love scenes veer between Puccini-like verismo and the works of Richard Rodgers.

Rising tension is signalled by menacing Hammer-horror ostinatos, and moments of heavy-handed satire that evoke the spirit of 1920s Kurt Weill.

And when O'Brien tells Winston that he must learn to love Big Brother he does so to a tune that really would be more appropriate for selling ice cream than as the climax of a supposedly serious opera.


With all these borrowings Mr. Maazel should bring it to America -- where he'd be acclaimed a GENIUS!

Home
Site Meter eXTReMe Tracker