Eugene David
...The One-Minute Pundit

Friday, March 24, 2006


Second thoughts from those LOVERS of POP CULTURE:

DEAD HUMOR [John Derbyshire]

I used to think Peter Sellers was the funniest man alive. The other day, however, I watched
A Shot in the Dark, the 1964 movie that established the Inspector Clouseau character. It really wasn't very funny at all.

We all know, of course, that humor is perishable, and that what made our parents -- or even our younger selves -- laugh can leave us stone faced. There are degrees of perishability, though, and the very best humor can stay funny for decades. I thought Sellers was in that league. Nope. His repertoire was narrower than I'd remembered -- really just two or three funny voices and a couple of facial expressions. It's sad... Though now I don't feel quite so bad at never having found Charlie Chaplin the least bit funny.

Posted at 10:24 AM

----------------------------------------------------------

RE: DEAD HUMOR [Warren Bell]

I often wonder about that, Derb. I think I've written here before about the disaster that is viewing
Blazing Saddles at age 42, after having wallowed in its glory at age 13. I think our memories tend to put a rosy glow around things we laugh at, and then in revisiting, the reality destroys the glow. I always cite "Bart the Genius" as one of my favorite Simpsons episodes, primarily because it was the first one I ever saw, and it just blew me away. In watching the DVDs with my kids, I notice that those first few episodes were pretty creaky in places. They didn't really hit their stride for another season or so, but that's not how I remembered it. So how much is the fault of memory, and how much is our own evolution in life? Is Sellers less funny, Derb, or are you?

Posted at 10:46 AM


We won't touch that LAST sentence, WARREN, but we will say this is from the IDIOTS who are always raving YOU-KNOW-WHAT COMEDY SHOWS as THE GREATEST OF ALL TIME.

Home
Site Meter eXTReMe Tracker