Eugene David
...The One-Minute Pundit

Saturday, February 17, 2007


A TNR writer propsoes a new national weekly book review. It sounds like a good (or at least well-meaning) idea until you start to think of it. With publishers disgorging a mountain of words even the most dedicated of magazines will let some works worthy of publicity languish. And who is to say that the problem is not enough well-written reviews but too many books? Wouldn't even the most discriminating of reviews get swamped? And where precisely will we find writers for it? Edmund Wilsons do not exactly flourish in publishing or academe these days. And who would pay them? Moreover Mr. Herf sems to limit himself to scholarly tomes, desiccating the air considerably. Besides we already have the New York Review of Books, which one correspondent here calls "comically narrow", and the Paper of Re-CORD's Book Review, which can be comically trendy. We've not counted the deluge of "reviews" on Amazon.com. Methinks we have enough scribble about books as it is.

Home
Site Meter eXTReMe Tracker