Eugene David
...The One-Minute Pundit

Monday, January 19, 2009


The Paper of Re-CORD's cri-TICS always look forward fanny-first:

Fifty-five years on, the Wyman and Hudson performances seem almost equally as studied and poised as those of Dunne and Taylor. What happened in the interim, of course, was the even greater revolution of Method acting. Already in the air in 1954 (the year of “On the Waterfront”), the Method would soon be established as the new standard of realism, consigning Hudson and Taylor alike to the dustbin of thespian history.

I can attest that Hudson’s performance earned howls of laughter at film society screenings in the mid- ’70s, at the moment when Robert De Niro and Al Pacino were scaling the Method heights. But if viewers feel less inclined to laugh at Hudson now, it may be because the cracks in the Method have begun to appear, and Mr. De Niro and Mr. Pacino (as in, for example, the recent “Righteous Kill”) themselves now seem mannered and quaint.

Believability, this fine set reminds us, is a constantly moving goal: it is no sooner reached than it recedes again.


As we say too often, and especially given the source, NUF SAID.

Home
Site Meter eXTReMe Tracker